Five teens that seem to have all had a prank pulled on them. One teacher that never allows phones in his class, finds phones on all of the kids- phones they say aren’t even theirs! Still, a rule is a rule, so they all get detention after school.
It is an unlikely bunch – the school drug dealer, the class valedictorian (or almost), the rising baseball star who will probably sign an MLB deal right out of high school, and the homecoming queen. Plus Simon. Simon is the interesting one. He, after all, knows all the dirt in the school. He knows stuff that no one else knows, and what makes it all crazy is that it is true. Simon publishes it all on a app that everyone has, so everyone knows all the secrets they shouldn’t.
No one understands why they are there. Until one of them isn’t. Simon has an allergic reaction and is rushed to the hospital…where he later dies. It turns out, someone must have slipped him some peanut oil – which he was deathly allergic to – with leathal consequences. Everyone in the room suddenly becomes a suspect.
And it turns out everyone had a motive because Simon was about to post a damaging message to his app that concerned all of the detention students. The question becomes, who did it, how and why?
Bronwyn, Addy, Nate and Cooper all find themselves placed under suspicion by the police and by their fellow students. Could one of them really have hated Simon so much that they killed him for it? As their lives begin to unravel with all that is revealed, it begins to look like there is no way to escape Simon, even after his death.
One of Us Is Lying by Karen McManus is a fast paced suspense book that will keep you hanging till the end. Make sure you have a nice long weekend to devote to this book, because once it gets going you won’t want to stop. Recommended for middle of the year 8th graders and up. Enjoy! I sure did!